Also, you make a lot of important points about the appeals of oral sex. And I'll pay attention to her slurping for sure
You reminded me of a list I've made some time ago here (before
this more general one but also related), and you motivated me to elaborate. If I was to make the list of my sub- or co-fetishes (meaning something that enhances the oral part itself), those would be, including and expanding on your list and my previous one:
My criteria for a great blowjob scene (update 1)
1. Principles and play (partially overlaps with the technique subsection; to improve later)
- Preferably 1 on 1, though I certainly dig the "line of dicks" sub-genre — it's just that the quality of play almost always suffers with the increase of the number of people involved; also, "harem" oral scenarios is a fetish that we have discussed a lot here
- Preferably no forcing*, even better if the guy does not touch the girl at all, i.e. she has full control and all the opportunities to shine (to use the same great word you used); thankfully, the Japanese culture seems to share this attitude, hence such prevalence of the "masochistic men", "herbivores" etc.; also, naturally, some characters and settings further enhance this (e.g. female teacher in an all-boy school, nurse collecting semen samples, etc.); also thankfully, JAV even has a whole sub-genre for it: self-deepthroat (セルフイラマ) — I elaborated on this point even further in another thread (here and here)
- No vomit, so slapping the girl, no spitting on her face, etc.*
- The more sounds the better (though this depends on the girl), but not too loud
- Spit is more than welcome, of course, and it's anothersub-fetish: there is a lot you can do with it, but for now, just a few things: bubbles (of the mixture of spit, precum, cum etc.), drops on the floor (it's not that easy to find a movie where the camera work capitalizes on that by taking long shots of the "mixture" puddle growing by focusing on it and staying there while more drops fall in; two good examples are the first scene in this and the one with the sailor suit in this)
- Precum play is great; actually, I think it's only in JAV that I realized how much play can be built around it (though there is a Western scene I remember to this day because of the string of precum slowly extending and the girl shaking making it move): from the girl making "threads" of precum from the cockhead to her finger to teasing when the precum stain is shown growing more and more
- Cum play, naturally, but I wanted to focus on the more overlooked sub-fetishes as well: first, it's cum drops on the floor and clothes (the more the better, especially on the girls's thighs when she's kneeling); second, the after-orgasm cum play (even BJ-focused movies often just discard the cum or show it for mere seconds... もったいない; I actually mention this in the opening post of this thread, calling it "cum-in-mouth-then-spit-out-on-palm", also linking to a related thread, and here is an example of this performed perfectly, with cum splashes)
- Finishes, by order of preference: oral cream-pie (with play afterwards as described in the previous point preferred; if it's swallowing, then it should be with mouth shown "before and after"****, and audible gulps are another turn-on), throat cream-pie, facial*****
- Other enhancers (to be elaborated later): dirty words** (the overall anatomy-focus, following the whole process of getting the cum out of the balls, through the penis, and into the mouth and throat of the girl, but also comments on hardness, amount stored, thickness etc., teasing with "I'll make you feel good with my throat" etc.), penis play (physically playing with it, shaking it, slapping her face and other body parts with it, checking its "spring power", measuring it with body parts, objects, rulers etc., erection process focus, morning wood, bulges, "elephant pants"...), ball play...
2. Technique
- BJ-only, no hands, slow, sensual, with lots of dirty talk (I know some Japanese, so it's a factor), and lots of ball and head licking with popping sounds
- Deepthroat: depends actually (with some girls, open-mouth looks and sounds sexier, with some, it's the sound they make with their throat etc.; audible sounds of entering the throat are a huge bonus)
- Bonus points: trying talking with her mouth full, making "struggling" noises (probably the best one I know is Kouya Satsuki, e.g. in TMDI-077), slurping (not too loud, though), "sign of relief" (reminded by Kaise Anju while re-watching XRW-511; see the scene on the couch in the middle; it also reminded me of Audrey Holiday, who makes these "refreshing!" sighs a lot)
3. Actress appeals
- Physical attributes are a plus (big tits and ass), but have low priority, apart from the thighs of the woman kneeling (this is a huge turn-on for me if they are thick, and porcelain-white, and bare, and, as mentioned above, have drops of spit, precum and cum on them; a good example of super-sexy hips is the first scene here), lips and tongue (plump lips and long tongue are always a plus)
- Assertive or even aggressive female role types, characters etc. (as noted above, this can be due to the role in the movie, e.g. a teacher, but it can also be types like dominatrix, mature, gyaru etc.)
4. Actor appeals (aka "the cock and balls")
- Cock: long but "more long than thick", curved (not any kind of curve, but an "arch" one, so to speak, i.e. curved as a bridge, not as a winding road), which we've come to call the "configuration" here
- Balls: big, hanging, descended enough for the actress to at least "pop" them with her mouth, but ideally, to grab and tug on them
- Cum: depends on the play (thick white blobs are good for the "thickness play", and liquid puddles are great for splashes, duh)
5. Camera work and positions
- Different angles, but mostly from the side, with some "softcore" shots where the action is not visible, only audible, but we see the spit drops, see the girl's head bobbing from behind etc.; POV is minimal; BONY-055, one of the latest works by Nakamura-san, gives a lot of insight into how fresh camera angles make the familiar stuff feel new (he might have used angles like these before, but again, that's the title that reminded me of it recently)
- Ability to change the angle is great, but not as it's achieved via VR but by having multiple camera angles to switch between (I've only seen this in Western porn, but there is at least one title where the same scene is shown two times from different angles, one after another)
- If it's one on one, the girl kneeling is probably the way to go, filmed from the side, as mentioned already; there is a huge appeal to 69, of course, as it allows for great cocks displays, sometimes even better than the couch does (see below); if it's 2+ girls, however, the best position is probably on the couch/bed, with the camera filming the cock from the feet/knees perspective, i.e. we can see the balls as well, so the process of the girls sharing the cock is seen the best (though the side angle words here as well)
6. Setting and outfits
- Overall vibe of semen removal is great; as for the preferable "relationship", they are, from highest to lowest: nurses/patient, teacher/student, "sister/brother", "mother"/"son", "childhood friend"/guy, "friend's mother"/guy (plus, I have a thing for "dick prison" setting, e.g. VOSS-133, though it's not BJ-only)
- The setting facilitating the fetish appeals above is better, of course, e.g. solid flooring that does not absorb the spit/cum and makes it clearly visible is preferable (wooden floor and leather couches are among the best surfaces for oral scenes); if the liquids are not visible, they should at least be audible, e.g. the aforementioned spit drops on the floor should be loud and clear
- Couches are particularly good as they allow for a specific angle I like, which is when the guy is sitting on the couch, and the girl(s) is on the couch kneeling at his side, as it allows for possibly the best cock displays
- Of course, appropriate outfits are huge boosters, but there is no problem with that in JAV (at least I don't remember any instances of this issue)
- As for the females/males being fully clothed/naked or not (CFNM etc.), for me, it depends, though, again, the right outfit is more often a good thing than not (e.g. the sexy thighs can be accentuated by a skirt, which is actually true for the example scene I gave above)
7. Additional qualities
- Of course, the higher the resolution the better usually
- As for the mosaics, I've gotten used to it, and more often than not, in JAV, censoring is for the better (hides the cocks if they're big but actually gross-looking and/or weirdly-shaped and evens out the color if they're actually unappealing shades, especially the dick head, etc. — which reminds me that there was at least one shota-themed hentai anime where the mature women were praising the young cocks for how they are still pink and not dark)
- I've come to appreciate the lighting a lot, and the same goes for the choice of color temperature
* Some exceptions exists, of course, which I
also shared already in another thread
** A great dirty-talk series comes to mind:
Dirty-Talking Female Announcer; also, the overall talkative atmosphere is great (
one of my favorite examples); bonus points for
female operators talking with the actress
*** I already mentioned several movies exemplifying this in the opening post, the "general list" linked above and
elsewhere, but there is
a particular title I just remembered (the girl checks how much the cocks grow thanks to her deepthroat "care")
**** Meaning before and after swallowing, but there is also another "before and after" that
can be discussed here
***** Swallows and facials
can be outstanding as well, of course