Help deciding which encoded video looks better

[SamKook]

I was tweaking the settings of my encodes and I was wondering if I could get the opinion of a few people to decide which looks better, or if you even see a difference at all.

Everyone opinions are welcomed.

Here are the 2 video to compare(414MB file):
http://fileuplo.de/gpe3wt3r8hi1.html test1
http://fileuplo.de/e1da4n5hrrn5.html test2


http://ryushare.com/iike1n23vzbt/MXBD-020_test1.rar
http://ryushare.com/hvkwphcya2mi/MXBD-020_test2.rar

They are 1080p mkv so you need to be able to play those.

 

[savajex]

I couldn't tell the difference at all. But I have to tell you, I'm not one of those people who can notice very minute differences. They both seemed good. I could see all her goosebumps in the bathroom.

Is there a specific difference I should be looking for? uzzled:

Btw, that guy in the beginning, on the right, was butt-ugly. andalaugh:

 

[Moxy]

I can't see any major difference between the two to be honest but at 1:56, the lips look more shiny in Clip 2. Its very negligible but I ran this on a monitor and not a TV so I'm not sure if there would be a difference there.

 

[SamKook]

Thanks for the help, I was hoping to get a little more opinions, but it will have to do.

I personally can't notice any difference, but I only have a 720p TV.

The difference between the two for me is that the second test is 3 times faster to encode and produce files that are a little smaller, but in theory it might be of slightly lesser quality.

If nobody can see the difference between the two(or like their lips shinier), it's win-win for everyone.