In Japanese porn culture the idea is that the body can't help reacting to being r***ing and eventually hitting orgasm. The more extreme version is the mind break but even in less silly movies it's the kind of "betrayal of the body". Japanese people are supposed to be in control of their outward appearance and mannerisms and losing control is played for kink and for fun.
For example comedy characters often stick their tongues out when they laugh because they are supposed to be idiots who can't control their reaction. Same with the forced orgasms, it's part humiliation and part her losing to the bad guys.
Yes and I LOVE how that dynamic is explored and illustrated in JAV (More on this below). Building the scenes to a boil where the girl is resisting and resisting and then all of the sudden you see her face awash in pleasure and her body convulse...
There is a lot going on in those movies. For example you get the soapland ones where the guy recognizes the woman. At the moment basic level it's a reversal of power, instead of her being in control of what happens and taking his money suddenly he has something over her. They usually throw in another kink as well, like it's his mom or a childhood bully or his boss or something.
I sometimes enjoy those movies. The family stuff is creepy but there is one specific thing I like which is where she begs him not to cum in her and he does it anyway. I don't like the forced aspect but I like nakadashi and especially the woman's reaction to it. Too many actresses don't react at all and the guys just stop and pose for the pull out shot immediately, but in those scenes there is reaction from both of them and some kind of connection.
Obviously would prefer if they just did that with non-r*** scenes but you take what you can get.
NOTE: I included links to all referenced JAV scenes at the bottom of this post.
One of my favorite aspects of the JAV industry is the themes. The Japanese directors utilize themes, and heavily nuanced yet simple plots to build tension and steam up the actual sex scenes with such consummate skill.
For instance, BDD-40 and BDD-41, a boxer and a martial artist must defend themselves against Corn Pop and some bad dudes. They get beat up at first, but bring back their boss man to settle the score.
In both movies, the female lead agrees to a winner take all style fight, where she proceeds to lose and get gangbanged by the invading group, in front of her trainer/trainees. Oh man what a hot couple of scenes. The tension and the fight scenes draw you into the situation, especially when the females take breaks during the fight competition part of the scene to consult with their trainers when they know they are in trouble, and therefore start to process what is in store for them as they slowly lose the battle and give up in exhaustion and defeat. Of course they start out just submitting their bodies to the victors once the fighting matches are over, but once they start getting fucked they can't hold back the orgasms, and they let it happen in a way that communicates their respect for the deal. Exceptional stuff.
A few other ones that share this type of fighter challenge build up and power dynamic -
SVDVD-059
SVDVD-090
SVDVD-485 (Fairly certain this is a one and done actress too which is impressive)
SDDM-556
There is also the classic KARMA series where the japanese girl is in LA for a job, only to realize she must have sex with not only several gatekeepers, but all their friends. Final scene involved actress getting a train run on her and creampied by 20 LA black dudes only to find out, there is no job, leaving her exhausted and leaking (fake) cum. Not my all favorites, but I respect the setup and execution is also enjoyable. Most notable in my book is KRMV-304.
A few of the Magic Mirror scenes are like this, where the girl is "very reluctant" only to cream over and over again once she starts getting pounded by her sweaty black partner. Not exactly r***, but super hot power dynamic, as in it is clear the girl needs the money and is very conflicted, only to submit and basically let the man use her until she cums uncontrollably and is unable to hide her own pleasure.
Their reaction to the creampie is also just amazingly hot. It is the development of the tension, and the relief of that tension through her submission that makes these works of art worth mention. DVDMS-362 is a notable title that demonstrates the ability of Japanese directors to pull such an impressive element of shame, submission, pleasure and excitement/embarrassment out of the talent. DVDMS-149 is pretty good too.
SVDVD-485 is a lot of fun and has a similar reluctant participant who ends up loving the double team.
In FAX-340 there is a scene where this guy hides from a few gangsters who he owes money to, only to have his sister show up looking for him. The gangsters talk briefly to the sister, explain the situation, and that there is a score to settle. the girl, protecting her brother, offers to settle the debt herself. The three men take her into the woods, where they run a train on her, one after another, with the brother watching from the bushes, crying. When they are all finished, they walk away, leaving her to clean herself up, and put her dirty panties back on. Unbelievably hot scene. (Not IR but still it is awesome and worth watching)
The ones where the mother protects her son from bullies are pretty hot too, especially when they use relatively new yet mature actresses, who take 4 dicks at once! The neighborhood bully ones that offer a similar bill of goods are also pretty hot when the actresses get into it, although some of them are a bit flat. (Not IR but still good examples of the dynamic).
In KRMV-311 (I believe it is second scene) the husband sends his wife into a tent full of dirty homeless men for a thrill. They pull her inside, gangbang her, then throw her out partially clothed, cum all over her and pretty torn up. Husband watches and wife clearly gets off on being used. (Again not IR but the dynamic is super hot).
HND-475 is another non-IR title that has such a hot setup. Adorable and very young looking 20yr old girl is making her porn debut "To pay her brother's school tuition". Much older dudes double team her, creampie her, and make her swallow their cum. She is reluctant but orgasms over and over again while crying out throughout the movie. The build it up in every scene too, how shy and reluctant but compliant she is to get through the whole deal. I don't care if it is all fake, they sell the whole scene as it relates to the title very very well. Great stuff.
This is just a sample from my collection, but as you all know there are many many others that demonstrate the point just as well.
Most of them are hilariously bad. The guys come over as nice dudes most of the time, although a few turned out to be douchbags, trying to hide infections and shit like that.
What usually ruins it is the girls talking bullshit and the guys going limp and struggling to cum then a really weak and shallow creampie that makes it looks like they just felt really bad about the whole situation and didn't want to even lean in to the racist fantasy. No connection, no real reaction. We aren't dumb, we know that if he pulls 95% out she can't feel his orgasm.
I spent over a decade viewing US porn exclusively, mostly IR. To say that most of them are bad is certainly an opinion you are entitled to, and one I respect, as everyone has different preferences with numerous facets and contingencies.
US porn is for the most part unimaginative and the industry has had no shortage of wacky scandals. I tend to overlook most of the extemporaneous industry activity providing it does not materially affect the producers/actresses I like best.
That being said, with specific reference to Dogfart and my example of InterracialBlowBangs (Although Dogfart has a stable of labels that range from consistently good to pretty laughable), there are plenty of scenes that are exceptional - where the actress is soooo into it and the male talent tee her up, one after another, some even slipping in the surprise creampie to the amusement of the rest of the crew. Those are choice scenes, but certainly don't make up the majority of the scenes offered by that particular label. There are plenty of mediocre scenes that possess the attributes you mentioned. There are also some out right shitty ones where everyone seems to be like "is it over yet?" with no attempt to hide the limp dicks or crazy fake creampies.
However, to brand most of them as hilariously bad is not something I agree with, although your observations certainly apply to plenty of the scenes on that label and some of the other DogFart labels.
With respect to US IR porn compared to JAV IR porn, I discovered JAV relatively recently, and it blew me away. As I said earlier, most US IR porn is unimaginative (There are plenty of exceptions, but overall, based on my observations across producers and directors and labels over many years, I stand by this assertion) and lazy compared to JAV IR. However, there are plenty of instances of quality scenes that end up buried to an extent, as Dogfart puts out soo much product, the gems are indeed easy to miss.
Have a look at the following examples -
Lily Rader
https://www.pornpics.com/galleries/...iny-pussy-nailed-face-jizzed-in-bbc-gangbang/
Moka Mora
https://www.pornpics.com/galleries/...xwell-moka-mora-ray-black-slim-poke-54330715/
Carolina Sweets
https://www.pornpics.com/galleries/...ets-goes-black-with-5-muscular-guys-97995633/
Cindy Lou
https://www.pornpics.com/galleries/...atural-tits-for-total-gangbang-jizz-coverage/
https://www.pornpics.com/galleries/...-bangs-a-bbc-at-a-gloryhole-in-black-sandals/
Brooklyn Chase
https://www.pornpics.com/galleries/...huge-black-cock-through-a-gloryhole-65221223/
https://www.pornpics.com/galleries/...a-massive-facial-after-a-black-cock-gangbang/
https://www.pornpics.com/galleries/...oklyn-chase-enjoys-hard-interracial-gangbang/
https://www.pornpics.com/galleries/...slim-poke-tone-capone-tony-eveready-26814763/
Blake Rose
https://www.pornpics.com/galleries/...-fucking-her-behind-the-wall-but-he-is-black/
Summer Carter
https://www.pornpics.com/galleries/...up-black-men-and-drains-their-dicks-of-sperm/
Tweety Valentine
https://www.pornpics.com/galleries/...tine-gets-banged-and-facialed-by-black-bulls/
Amatuer Cindee
https://www.pornpics.com/galleries/...es-an-interracial-gangbang-in-her-porn-debut/
Angel Smalls
https://www.pornpics.com/galleries/...es-on-garage-full-of-bbb-in-intense-gangbang/
Zoey Laine
https://www.pornpics.com/galleries/pigtailed-zoey-laine-getting-banged-by-a-group-of-wild-black-men/
Liza Rowe
https://www.pornpics.com/galleries/...s-rocked-by-two-monster-black-dicks-58217010/
That is just a sampling, but as you can see, not all Dogfart scenes are "created equal".
Storylines are simple and buildup is much shorter than JAV, but to address your criticisms, you can see within this sampling that plenty of their scenes are not just hot, but display enthusiasm and solid performances on the parts of both the male and female talent.
JAV IR, in general, goes to great lengths to develop the scenario in which the physical sex act(s) will take place, in order to feed the psychological needs of the viewer. The eroticism in JAV IR is built up usually well in advance of the sex act, so by the time it starts, the viewer is hooked in a psychological, physical and physiological sense.
I admire the efforts of Japanese directors in their artistic abilities to meet these multidimensional needs of their audience and in many cases, exceed them when it comes to intensity of the scene, characters, backdrop, etc. I get the distinct impression there is a ton of coaching of the talent to ensure the scene plays as it should in order to ensure the viewer is truly sold on the whole experience. Not every scene achieves this obviously, but when they do, it is pretty magical.
Included links below to every JAV scene mentioned above for your ease and reference (Apologies for the unusually lengthy post):
BDD-40
http://www.javlibrary.com/en/?v=javliibrrq
BDD-41
http://www.javlibrary.com/en/?v=javliia47e
SVDVD-059
http://www.javlibrary.com/en/?v=javlicr5sa
SVDVD-090
http://www.javlibrary.com/en/?v=javliml434
SVDVD-485
http://www.javlibrary.com/en/?v=javliiztsq
SDDM-556
http://www.javlibrary.com/en/?v=javlia3n5m
KRVM-304
http://www.javlibrary.com/en/?v=javlidzb6u
DVDMS-362
http://www.javlibrary.com/en/?v=javli7tyze
DVDMS-149
http://www.javlibrary.com/en/?v=javlikqv2a
SVDVD-485
http://www.javlibrary.com/en/?v=javliiztsq
KRMV-311
http://www.javlibrary.com/en/?v=javlidzbya
HND-475
http://www.javlibrary.com/en/?v=javli43j6m