My vote for tops are:
117 for #1 (the outbreak of real tears also the whole "hunting" thing worked and also the special occasion + grandiose )
123 for #2 (just overall a good vid)
119 for #3??? (it lost a lot of points for a few issues) tonight I will go home to watch 107 and I picked out another cover that I will give a try. May be knock 119 off top 3...
So having gone over 107 (ZUKO's entry to AVOP)... I'd say... it's one of the better vids from ZUKO, but it probably can't knock off 119. It comes to a weird situation. Which is a better porn film? Then 107 is better than 119 (Moodyz crazy all-star fest). But which one is an award winner in AVOP? Then... is 107 really outstanding among the ZUKO series? Not particularly, the 8 women are good looking enough. And the big plus over 127 (the 7 sisters one) is that they are distinguishable from each other. Firstly Ayumi is the quintessential slutty mom, couple girls are the standard largish tits hotties, one (AIKA?) is a GAL with faked tan and dyed blonde, the two little sisters can probably satisfy the loli fans (or not?) and the "wife" in the story is distinguishable for being distinctively unattractive. It's a good harem with a mix of orgy and one-on-one. Nice variety in terms of face and body type (what's the point of multi-girls if all of them look and sound and fuck the same way?). But it's a POV film, and not dicing any words, POV is L.A.M.E. And it's one of the "baby-making" genre that's completely taken over ZUKO, which is sad. And I'd appreciate a bit more personality and sex style to go with the looks of each girl. (Mom should be more cougar, GAL should be more cock-hungry in a self-absorbed way, the loli could be more "innocent" etc) And a HUGE minus is the wife, I believe she's Kamihata Ichika 神波多一花, is there ever a woman who have no reason to have an AV career that's her. Like, I'm not a big fan of certain girls (AIKA being one), but I fully understand there's a market for her look or some other quality (A-cup, loli, fat chick etc), but what's the market/genre for Kamihata Ichika, I don't get it! And she's pretty active in AV even, I just managed to fail to see her in any vid until now.
Anyway... back to 119, with 18 girls, many of them S-class, for a 4-hour vid, probably costed 10 million yens in production... kind of like.... hmm despite somehow it's not a great porn, you still have to say it has an edge over 107 in AVOP award.
And then... I really have to thank
@Supmop for the challenge when I already gave up on AVOP 2015, I went back to go over the covers again in search of alternative winners... and spotted 164. Rope bondage with a couple A-class (perhaps not quite S-class) names, and intriguing "original work" (原作) only problem was the photo work on the cover was rather unflattering. Turns out it's quite a great rope bondage vid, probably the best rope bondage vid I've ever seen. I've always like the idea of rope bondage but never seen a satisfactory vid. Here everything worked out, the girls are fine looking (not super busty but supple D- or E- cups) they look good in kimono and flight attendant uniform, the rope work isn't over elaborate yet expertly, the men wear a very respectable exterior and creepy sick sadist inside. The teasing (especially teasing the tits) was well done and well-filmed, along with plenty of honest fucking of the mouth and pussy, and quite good cumshots. The final scene has some nice teasing of the anus and a nice big shot of enema. Even the lighting was perfect. Normally these vids need to be dimly lit for the atmosphere but usually it ends up not able to see anything and I tend to fall asleep.
The three ladies of 164 かすみ果穂, 大槻ひびき, 阿部乃みく ALL appeared in 107 as well. I believe they are the two hotties and one of the lolis in 107. But for now I can't identify the actress names in both 107 and 164. Help is deeply appreciated:
So final point is: the vid was so good I had to look up the "original work" aspect. Turns out the original was a novel by the late
Oniroku Dan (团鬼六) and I learn that he's the famous S&M writer behind the cult film series Flower and Snake. From the huge number of Attacker trailers at the end of 164, I notice quite a few AV had been made of his novel. Maybe worth a look.