Sorry, you're right. It's just that as someone who has lived in Japan for ages, and has a huge number of Japanese friends, acquaintances, and enemies, I suppose I get a bit frustrated by abstract analyses of "Japanese society," "Japanese culture," "Japanese people," etc. As you and guy know very well, the reality in here in Japan (like everywhere else on this planet) is enormously complex, and there is enormous difference among individuals, not to mention regional differences, differences over time, etc. But most people who do not speak the language and have not spent a lot of time here tend to accept very broad stereotypes as truth. So when you or guy or I say something about Japan, among ourselves we may understand perfectly what the others are saying, because we have in-depth knowledge of the context, but other members may read what we write and interpret it in very different ways. So, for example, someone might read your previous post and think, "Oh, so Japanese people are immature." That is not, I believe, what you meant. And someone might read guy's post and think, "Oh, so in Japan, they are strict and rigid publicly, but in private, anything goes!" Again, I'm pretty sure that's not what guy meant.We are not getting off topic. The subject is doll-related.
On a life-sized doll thread are we all supposed to talk only about dolls? That will be rather weird. :dies:
IMO, there's no need to try to control threads in discussion sections. Getting off topic will be fine, too. We are not attending conferences or seminars, you know? Unless we adopt K15 system. :evillaugh:
I suppose I just hate generalizations about "a people," because it reinforces a tendency that many humans have of seeing their own society as complex, and other societies as somehow simple, or "backward," or even "primitive."
BTW, I feel the same way when I hear Japanese people making generalizations about "Americans" or "Westerners" (or any other peoples). So I speak up in such situations and say, "It's a lot more complicated than that."
So, that's my bottom line: "It's a lot more complicated than that."
In the case of love-dolls, I could go out on a busy street corner and conduct a survey. I could show people photos of various love-dolls, explain how they're made, how much they cost, what different types are available, and ask the people, "So what do you think of all this?" I suspect that common responses would include:
- "Eww. That's disgusting. I get sick just thinking about the kind of people who would buy these things."
- "HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA! That is so weird!"
- "Well, as long as the people who buy these things aren't hurting anyone, it doesn't bother me. To each his own."
- "I think these would be great for someone can't find a real lover for some reason."
- "Things like this might lead someone to commit a sex crime. They should be banned."
- "Whoa! These are so well made! And you say they cost about 600,000 yen? Wow. That's incredible. I had no idea."
- "Actually, I have that doll right there, but with a different wig. I call her Sayaka. I used to have this one, but there's no comparing soft vinyl and silicon."
:dunno: