Live Action and Original Source

vodanh1011

New Member
Sep 2, 2015
8
1
Hi guys, I am new here. I am not so much into JAV until I discover the new style of JAV which a live action adapt from various H- Manga, H-Anime and H-Game. Usually those fall on URE, MIMK, ZIZG company, anyone interested to discuss both live action and the original source, let chat up
 

Zen10101

Well-Known Member
Aug 20, 2008
857
1,154
Hello there..the only live action one I really liked is Taimanin Yukikaze, it's just so difficult for them to have the same level of intensity as H. I'm still hoping they'd produce live action versions of some of my favorite works from Lilith, especially the street alley gang bang scene from Dark Knight Ingrid
 

vodanh1011

New Member
Sep 2, 2015
8
1
I dont think they will do the Dark Knight Ingird, the H-anime is actually spin off from that Taimanin series. The first one i get is Hana-Hook adaption, quite nice and the director go as much as original
 

ding73ding

Akiba Citizen
Oct 25, 2009
2,337
2,092
I'm afraid it's a fad that's already fading. I still keep up with the ZIZG series, but there were quite a few forgettable films in last few month. (ZIZG-012 Prison Battleship Fortress City Brainwash is very good again, but still behind ZIZG-002 Prison Battleship in production value).

As for URE and MIMK, I haven't seen a good one for months, perhaps I missed a few.
 

vodanh1011

New Member
Sep 2, 2015
8
1
Indeed, the ZIZG-012 is actually little bit fail in my opinion. Perhaps I had not play the second game but character wise, i feel the actress is lacking in chest department. For URE and MIMK, they had out with few series. For example the latest of MIMK-036 is quite interesting. And the URE, well they seem like picking up the none famous series to make live action. Hope by next few month they pick better one I guess.

And to be honest, i make this thead to discuss more about the original series but if it fail, i may try at hentai discussion. But hopefully it is not violate the law
 

CodeGeek

Akiba Citizen
Nov 2, 2010
5,180
1,866
I'm not sure if it violates any forum rules, but a Hentai discussion somehow doesn't fit in the "JAV Discussion" section, doesn't it? ;)
 

vodanh1011

New Member
Sep 2, 2015
8
1
Perhaps, I am newbie so I just want to play safe by discuss this topic in JAV. Plus I want to find any guys/ladies have same taste as me to discus both the live action version and hentai version at the same time
 

ding73ding

Akiba Citizen
Oct 25, 2009
2,337
2,092
Don't worry I rarely see the mods taking action except for something really annoying. Anyway hentai and AV are obviously related topics so there's no need to make it a black and white issue.

I come at this genre not being a real fan of hentai. I loved Urotsukidoji and Cream Lemon back then but have outgrown it around the time of La Blue Girl (the anime). I loved La Blue Girl the movie(s) not so much they were great movies and/or porn but more like love the idea of it: bunch of folks rigging up rubber props and gel and writing a script and actors memorizing the lines to make a, essentially, a dildo porn lousy for masturbation.

I like some elements of hentai: crazy weird excuse to have sex, elaborate stories, and blend of other genres (such as SciFi, fantasy adventure etc) into sex, etc. Other aspect of hentai such as extreme humiliation/gang r***, mind break interest me a lot less. So perhaps we are not on the same page here...

I like ZIZG and a couple of older superheroine (Cybeeta) spoof vids because of the elaborate costume, CGI, sets, dialogues (even if I don't understand Japanese and not knowing the backstory of Taimanin, I get a kick out of watching AV idols string long sentences together and talking about demons and end of the world etc). Yes I can't wait for the sex to get on, but I also love watching the soon-to-be-fucked heroines getting physical with swords and staves and laser guns (love the cheap CGI laser beam and explosions).

There was also a early MIMK (correction: EBOD-313) which happens at a school and the protagonist (a female student) has to figure out a conspiracy by the principal and teachers who drug and r*** girls. I mean I am an old cynical guy when it comes to both porn and mainstream thrillers, but really when the girl was caught by the principal, strap on a evil-looking device and about to be r***ing, I got so into the story that I was as distressed as her and wishing that she can escape or be rescued and vanquish the evil, quite forgetting I had my pants down and my right hand firmly gripping my erect cock, waiting to jerk off to her ordeal.
ebod00313ps.jpg


I don't know, despite these live action hentai being such a joke, some of them I get more into the story than the latest Divergent or Maze Runner movie, or even Marvel... seriously I still don't have a clue what's Ultron and I don't F*CKING care!

Some of the other URE and MIMK live action hentai are fails in my book, not because they were good or poor re-creation of the original hentai (I don't know them anyway) because they are not really distinguishable from the average mainstream AV: one girl (maybe a top idol), several scenes, each with one or two guys, there's some excuse for them to have sex, they fucked they cummed that's it. If they keep picking those hentai that's easy/cheap to make in live action (no need for special sets or costumes) then it's just regular AV for me.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Motiman

vodanh1011

New Member
Sep 2, 2015
8
1
Indeed my friend. You had raise a lot of valid point but indeed we are not in same page here.

Personally if talk about crazy weird excuse to have sex, the normal JAV also have a lot, just that we, the outsider with no knowledge of Japanese had prevent us fully understand the normal JAV. And if the aspect of hentai such as extreme humiliation/gang r***, mind break, those usually torn down quite a lot since it is a live action, and they try to make a lot of stuff reasonable enough.

Indeed about, some works are superb while some are fail alot. MIMK got a lot fail live action while URE is not so bad, because most of their work come from good hentai doujishin writer. But well, we just have to deal with the failure normally as another JAV by delete that trashy and save the real good on.

But for my opinion, the ZIZG, the latest series in adaptation, they seem to choose the good hentai, found good script and director and shot quite a lot of quality work. Even though personally ZIZG-012 is little fail in my opinion but nonetheless it is still interesting to watch so far.

Oh, also there is new series, RMAN, from their poster and their first 2 live action, they focus and pick up the series of plump woman for their shot. I am not against it but not fond of it either. If you into well plump woman, then you can check it out
 

ding73ding

Akiba Citizen
Oct 25, 2009
2,337
2,092
Do you agree this exciting new trend (I don't remember seeing much of this 3 years ago) is already fading? In what way? And why (what's the cause of fading)? My "evidence" is that during my daily/weekly scanning of covers, I hardly see live action hentai's distinctive design any more, or it could just be in my heads...

To be fair, I'm still very interested in this genre, on average (even counting the fails) live action hentai is higher than JAV as a whole, which is numerically dominated by garbage (of course one man's garbage is yadda yadda yadda). So I would be quite happy if it becomes one of the "mainstream" genres like soapland so that every AV idols can be expected to make at least one vid in this genre.

Being a non-fan of hentai, obviously I have some beef with it. But I do like many aspects of hentai, so hopefully live action hentai can combine the best of both. Of course I recognize whatever that get my rocks off isn't the same for others. I'm open-minded about other tastes and favors.

One aspect that we might end up agreeing to disagree is the looks of the characters. I mean I am pretty picky about figures (and face too) but I wouldn't like a woman to be too perfect, especially I wouldn't want all female characters to look too similar and too perfect. Which is one of the big issue for hentai, every female characters look like a clone from a handful of stereotypes, the voluptuous MILF, the moe girl, the underage loli, the perfect goddess and that's about it...

So... say I'm a huge fan of Julia, mainly for her, pretty-much-perfect, manga-like figure. But then ... it can get tiresome if every vid is featuring her, or every other performer is surgically enhanced to the same manga-like figure. So I' happier with live action hentai's characters not quite as cartoonish as the original source. The point isn't to re-create the same look from one medium to next, it' to modify it to be surprising and familiar at the same time.

RMAN... I remember this code prefix, but found none of the HDD... could be I deleted it already??
 

vodanh1011

New Member
Sep 2, 2015
8
1
Personally I am not sure that it is already fading or not due to lack of many year research into JAV. But if you said it had started to lose its value then I guess the reason is that when they start they choose carefully which hot doujinshi and possible consult the author when they develop it. Then after awhile, the scriptwriter is too confident and just get the scene out of his ass rather want to follow the story or they make mistake then pick up the wrong series when they are adapt. Possible the time they pick it, it is like new hot, but by the time they finish every thing to publish the live aciton, the fanbase had moved on another story.

Well, I am not sure about your opinion about it since you seem quite fond of JAV so...

Anyway, about the look of characters, I think I did not explain clearly. I do not mean that the character need to look similar and perfect. But I just want they are little bit closer to the series about the figures, while face you can adjust by using make up. For example the main female is big boobs which is the big point to draw the people in, you can not put a small boobs into the live action. It make you feel little bit disappointed.

And yes, one of big issue for hentai is that they are little bit similar and like a clone from quick look. But if you do little bit more reading some good doujinshi then you will pick out different artist have different way. But since you are not really fan of hentai, it is like tell me which JAV actor really good at faking her orgasms and which one is way too fake.

Julia? Can you please enlighten this newbie some of her series. May be I watch her somewhere but like I said, I am now a little bit more into plot and acting rather just good figures, face and moaning.

RMAN, perhaps you had deleted it, after all your taste sometime shift alot. Like last year, I am okay as long as it is good big boobs, now I am more into MILF lady or Mature woman (rage from 25-40)
 

EroMura777

Active Member
Apr 5, 2015
268
209
If you want Julia in some other media adaptation, you have MIMK-015 and MDYD-759, for example. In general, in my opinion, her acting is a bit tame, like she could do more, but her body is just perfect.
 

vodanh1011

New Member
Sep 2, 2015
8
1
Oh, I remember her now. But it is always like that, we expect they can be more but they had done their best, so well, sometime need to lower the bar to them.

Also I just do some research on my own, and I am not sure why but URE producer seem like hardcore fan of "Chuuka Naruto " artist since quite number of their project using materials from him. I think that's why the reason for this genre being drop down as they use professional and old man actor. No offence but that little bit turn off. They do pick up another good artist "TsuyaTsuya" and "Takasugi Kou" 's work and deliver such a good work then back to old guy and BDSM again. That's may be the reason this Live Action area get less and less land to improve
 

ding73ding

Akiba Citizen
Oct 25, 2009
2,337
2,092
ZIZG-013 Captive Market
h_826zizg00013ps.jpg


Can't wait for the torrent to finish... too bad it has yellow watermark. If anyone comes across a better version pls share the tip.

Another question is what's the original material, I suppose it's a Lilith game again? Are there any manga or CG arts from the original? Any help? @vodanh1011 ?

Ahh... finished download... looks pretty good. Long dialog scene to start, wonder what the story is...Kurea Hasumi still looks fake to me... but she's playing a fake space elf ehhh ... What's with the girl wearing space elf ears AND fuzzy bunny ears?
 

ding73ding

Akiba Citizen
Oct 25, 2009
2,337
2,092
The ones based on Hana Hook's Mangas are probably the best Manga to AV adaptions out there and you might wanna read the manga too, it's english translated and it lets you know what's going on in the movie version as well.
https://hitomi.la/galleries/777058.html

Thanks for linking the manga to the AV (URE-019) I am quite interested in these adaptions but always too lazy to dig up the original source.

But I do want to rant about the sad state of hentai and JAV (again).

To sum it all up, I think Losers (herbivore cherry boy 40 year old virgins sociopaths) have totally dominated the consumer base of JAV (and probably also AMG-anime manga games) and more and more I can't identify with them and I can't enjoy the AV's and hentai written and produced for these target audience.

Hana Hook's Hahaoya Shikkaku (Disgraceful Mother?) series is a perfect example, the protagonist is a weakling in both body and mind, he's small, frail, not very intelligent and socially dysfunctional. "Tormenting" him are women who are beautiful, smart and authoritative. The women (always including his mother) maybe less than kind to him, or they may be acting quite normal towards such a loser and they are only mean and spiteful in his sad sad imagination. And then somehow the loser boy get to torture all these women sexually.

OK sometimes I get my rocks off watching some undeserving guy have sex with a much superior woman/goddess, but it can only be a fringe or freakshow. Even with an asymmetric pairing I still don't need to see ether the men or women being hurt or torture against his/er will. I enjoyed quite a few S&M literature/productions including Urotsukidoji, back when it was an extreme. But now the "mainstream" seems more mental and dysfunctional then Urotsukidoji. Another comparison is with Western S&M culture, such as 50 Shades of Gray and Sleeping Beauty series by Anne Rice or Tanya Hyde's S&M porn (coincidentally it seems many of the masters of S&M are actually women: mistresses). Both the sadists and masochists are smart and beautiful and rarely have things done to them which is truly against their wills and desires.

Basically my porn need is that of a man who has plenty of experience and enjoyable and satisfactory sex life but with my high level of libido I'm never stop to check out hot women in real life and on TV scene and including seeing them nude and doing sex, especially seeing some super-hot women (generally out of my league) in some crazy sexual situation (orgy, outdoor, S&M/fetish especially with fancy/expensive costumes and gears).

Whereas the AV and hentai industry has the main audience are sexually, socially, and mentally disturbed, or even ... considering the wave of violence and terrorism world-wide... a hair-trigger away from some shocking violence against women, against society.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Hans Kowalski

jugulear

Akiba Citizen
Jan 20, 2012
2,769
2,313
.
Man, you are one heck of a connoisseur, Ding73ding... knowing all of the porn or quasi-porn ins-and-outs that leaves one gasping!

And kudos to you for preferring porn characters who are consensually on the straight and narrow (hmm! That's one of my gripes against Western, more specifically American, porn), and who are very healthy in their outlook. (Our friend Hans Kowalski may be with you, to some degree, on that one.) Your preferred male protagonist is a man-about-town whose masculine sex drive makes him look for greater opportunities.

Man Who Loved Women.jpg

Not the best analogy, but when I read that, I wondered if you (as a reflection of your preferred porn hero) could possibly be Burt Reynolds in THE MAN WHO LOVED WOMEN!

On the other hand, myself, I thought URE-019 was one of the best JAVs I've seen. (Touched on that morsel here.)

I don't know about your theory regarding "Losers (herbivore cherry boy 40 year old virgins sociopaths) have totally dominated the consumer base of JAV." (Porn actor Manlet, or Shimiken, has great contempt for this class of men, as we get the hint from this page's second article. Gee, Ding, did you not perhaps get carried away a little when you branded these lost souls as "sociopaths"?)

This new class of unassertive men (comprising well over half of Japanese men aged 20-34) is definitely a force to contend with (meaning, they could certainly affect JAV market dynamics), but this development of the "grass-eaters" is fairly fresh on the scene; I do not believe JAV (or even pre-JAV, i.e. softcore Japanese exploitation from the end of the last century) steered clear of the elements you are not enamored of. The concept of men succeeding in getting a leg up (or another bodily part up) with the ladies that are not always attainable — through devious means — has been around for a long time. (A quick and extreme non-porn example: REVENGE OF THE NERDS. Further: the nebbish character of Woody Allen in his first movies was one all men could appreciate, enjoying as we can the woman-tribulations of one less polished than we.)

No matter how normal a guy is in real life, with reasonable success in relation to women, the facts boil down to: we crave sex, and the women hold the cards. Getting the women via ignoble means in JAV serves as an attraction to most, as it fulfills the fantasy of bedding any woman we desire. (And that's the purpose porn mainly serves: fantasy.)

.