Hmm. Honest assessment? Quite a few flaws with her singing that even sound editing couldn't cover up. But the biggest criticism is that the song is meh...as in quite bland and forgettable. It lacks a hook and just doesn't stick in one's head. They need a better songwriter. If they're writing their own music, they either need to step it up or outsource.
You really have to be a Rei fan to like the song or listen to it more than once.
I'm not bothered if there is flaws with her singing as I more go with
the feeling. I grew up with punk, hardcore and metal so the song and her
singing works well with me. I like the song as well and it's memorable to me.
It's also a lot about personality. And Rei has a lots of it and it matters more than
if she can sing perfectly. Without personality there is no artist.
Just like Daffy088 wrote above you don't need musical perfection to make good rock.
Personally I would even prefer if Brats was even less produced and raw.
I do wish they could write their own songs. That they could get that support from
their agency/label. But reality is that many pop and rock bands in Japan have
song writers just as idol groups do. Kinda sad.
The girls are good musicians and I know Rei could write good lyrics considering
some of the things she written on her social media. I think they could do better
if they where encouraged to write their own material.
I haven't been able to find info who wrote this new Brats song. I only know in the past
they didn't write their own songs. Their song "14 Year Old Disease" was written by
Matsunaga Temma and her band Urbangarde arranged it for Brats. Temma was inspired by Rei
and wrote the song for her. Well it had at least more success than the two latest songs by Brats.
Well I'm more a Brats fan than Rei only fan. I'm in it for the music.
When it comes to Rei I'm into her voice and personality. Yes she is
beautiful. But my heart belongs to someone else.
Also I don't think Brats goal is to repeat the same success that Ladybaby
had. I think Brats is more serious than this and there is a big difference
between both groups. The Idol Formerly Known as Ladybaby are more
a idol group while Brats are a rock band. Also Ladybaby was actually started
as marketing gimmick for a clothing brand. And it's goal was to kinda shock
having Ladybeard in it. That is also a difference.
When it comes to Rei and Rie I think the producers should instead retired the
Ladybaby concept and instead formed a new group with focus on the girls talents and personalities.
The Ladybaby concept kinda was lost when Ladybeard no longer was a part of the group.
They got two really talented girls and they kinda waste it on trying to keep the old
concept alive.
I don't mean that these new songs by The Idol Formerly Known as Ladybaby are bad.
I kinda like them still. But there is clearly something missing there and I do
think the girls would do better if their had their own group/project instead.
I don't think Brats need to compete with other rock bands as they kinda
have their own thing. Like no one else can be Rei, Aya and Hinako. The girls
are unique. I do think they will succeed ahead.